- Rational Approaches to Healing
- Muscle Response Testing and Pitfalls
- Do-It-Yourself (DIY) Therapies
- Devices (Overview)
- Essences and Homeopathics
- Diets, Recipes and Homemade Interventions
- Drugs and Destructive Methods
- Issues with…
- Imbalances in…
- Circulation & Heart
- Structure, Bones, Joints, Teeth
- Lungs & Sinus
- Endocrines – Thyroid, Adrenals, Gonads
- Kidney and Bladder
- Liver & Gall Bladder
- Immune System
- Nerves and Brain
- The Skin
- The Eyes
- Client Info
Bones and Teeth
Making Bones and Teeth (a politically incorrect guide)
Bones and teeth are living tissue. Because they are harder than other living tissues in the body, that does not mean you need to eat calcium rock supplements or other non-food-like substances to make them hard. Yes, I’m bucking the daily 1200 mg calcium rule. From all my nutritional offerings, my clients have never tested for a rock-based calcium product to rebuild their bones, so I had to rethink this whole matter. What was the uncommon wisdom my arthritic and osteoporotic clients were showing me?
Bone is extraordinary structure, too. It’s stronger than cast iron in resisting compression but, if killed by X-rays or by cutting off its blood supply, it collapses into mush. From The Body Electric, Robert O. Becker, MD
Becker found that bone growth was restimulated by the introduction of electric currents.
My clients taught me that to build bone, one needs good circulation and and good enough digestion to break proteins all the way down to amino acids. After all, the bone matrix needs blood and proteins to build itself and then, after the matrix is built, it can hold minerals. So yes, bones need minerals, but before that, the ability to hold the minerals must be constructed. For this consider bone buiding soup.
The Calcium Issue in Relation to Bone Building
First of all, osteoporosis cannot be a calcium-deficiency disease. We consume more calcium per capita than any culture in the world and still have the highest levels of osteoporosis! So that ain’t it.
A number of studies have been done to examine the relationship between calcium and bones. A study by Mark Hegsted, Professor Emeritus of Nutrition at the Harvard School of Public Health, compared the rates of calcium intake to the risk of hip fracture by country. Surprisingly, he found that countries with low intakes of calcium actually had lower rates of hip fracture and countries with high intakes of calcium had higher rates of fracture. Hmmmmmmm. Stay with me.
Most calcium supplements aren’t ‘living food’. In fact they are chemically produced rock powders and when did humans ever eat rocks for food? In fact, alkalizing calcium supplements neutralize stomach acid needed to make materials for our tissue and bone repair. In postmenopausal women, it has been shown that about 40% are severely deficient in stomach acid. Neutralizing the little that is there severely affects your body’s ability to repair itself – including its bones! (BTW Taking a medication that lowers or inhibits stomach acid has the same effect. See Pharma Phactoids below).
Many people rely on milk as their source of calcium. But research has shown that people in countries with the highest dairy intake have the highest rate of hip fractures per capita. Furthermore, in the Nurses’ Health Study, a study involving 77,761 women, researchers found that women who drank two or more glasses of milk per day had a 45% higher risk for hip fracture compared with women consuming one glass or less per week. So forget pastuerized homogenized milk as a solution – it hastens bone loss.
More recent studies have looked at the relationship between calcium and bone density. Postmenopausal women were given various amounts of calcium daily. The results of the studies show that those with higher rates of calcium received a small initial benefit in greater bone density but that the effect did not continue to increase. So, except for a small, one-time benefit, higher daily intake of calcium did NOT appreciably strengthen bones.
And another thing to consider, denseness as measured by today’s diagnostic devices DOES NOT determine if the bone is living tissue or not.
Well if this paradigm shift is too much for you and you are fearful for your bone health and want to take a calcium, I recommend Herbal CA ATC (#826-3). It is an easy-to-digest concentrate from living plants with all the synergists and other ingredients needed for bone and tissue repair. Plus it calms the nerves and reduces some kinds of pain.
You make bone like you make brownies, with many kinds of ingredients carried to the site with good circulation. Although there are many supplements shown to be helpful ingredients for bone reformation (chondroitin, glucosamine, aminos, etc.), a more balanced program includes getting the bone ingredients from our foods in an assimilable form. The Bone Building Soup recipe shows how to extract bone rebuilding nutrients from the bones of animals in the form of a soup broth – made in your own kitchen. It is good for all kinds of illness and debility, and especially for the aged. The Easy Therapeutic broth can be used instead for those not in a position to cook. If the above studies don’t convince you, know this, that bone building requires many other players, synergists, transports, hormones, good capillary circulation, NOT calcium from rock powders.
The Hormone Issue in Relation to Bone Building
The thyroid makes 5 hormones that we know of; T1, T2, T3, T4, and calcitonin. Calcitonin, is key in calcium deposition. But if you are on a thyroid medication (like Synthroid), don’t assume you are getting calcitonin or that this man-made substitute for one of your thyroid secretions is doing everything that your own thyroid does for you. And bone loss is a side effect of Synthroid. Ask your pharmacist. And 1200 mgs of calcium won’t prevent this, nor will the other pharmaceuticals (Boniva, Actonel, Fosamax, Didronel, Skelid) do anything for your bones either (oh wait, they will cause osteo-necrosis of the jaw, a.k.a. jaw rot, i.e. bone death). You need to nourish your own thyroid into proper function so it can make all the hormones you need in the right amount at the right time. Begin with Thyroid Support (#1228-6) 3B. It will do more to support bone growth than rock powder calciums or synthetic thyroid hormone.
Menopause – the estrogen/progesterone connection
Women all over the world experience a lowering of estrogen at menopause, but not all women experience osteoporosis. Attributing the causes of osteoporosis to the natural lowering of estrogen at menopause is too simplistic. The fact is that Mayan Indian women, Bantu women of Africa and the Japanese all have lower estrogen levels than US women, but they all experience much fewer fractures than US women (they are probably not taking rock calcium powder). Furthermore, while a decrease in estrogen level is one contributing factor to osteoporosis, this alone does not explain the disease, as osteoporosis also occurs in men (though much less frequently).
So what might be in the Japanese diet? Some suggest soy but it occurs to me that the seaweeds they eat are highly beneficial not only to supply minerals for the bone but also food for the thyroid gland which is a backup endocrine for the ovaries and produces calcitonin. Therefore supplementing with kelp and algae are a natural way to address this aspect of bone growth (or use Thyroid Support (#1228-6) if you have been diagnosed with low thyroid).
In the Scientific American’s Updated Medicine Text, 1991 it states “Estrogens decrease bone resorption” but “associated with the decrease in bone resorption is a decrease in bone formation. Therefore, estrogens should not be expected to increase bone mass.” Your doctor may want to know this.
Living bone tissue is broken down and rebuilt continuously, just like all of the living tissue in our body. This process takes place when osteoclasts help to dissolve old bone tissue, while osteoblasts stimulate new bone growth. Because estrogen has a rate limiting effect on osteoclasts, ‘estrogen dominance’ delays the breakdown of bone tissue but does not support bone building (osteoblast function). Therefore estrogen actually inhibits the rebuilding process. No reason to do estrogen for bone density.
The efficacy of natural progesterone, however, is verified by a three year study of 63 post-menopausal women with osteoporosis. Women using transdermal progesterone cream experienced an average 7-8% bone mass density increase the first year, 4-5% the second year and 3-4% the third year! Untreated women in this age category typically lose 0.7% to 2.0% bone density per year!!! So applying a small amount of progesterone cream is beneficial and supportive of bone reformation. Short term you can use Pro-G-Yam (500 mg (2 oz. tube) # 4936-5) to stimulate the osteoblasts in the event that your hormones are the contributing factor. I also recommend Adrenal Support (#1507-0) since your adrenals are your backup for all hormones made by the body, and can make the progesterone that your body needs in the right amount at the right time.
The Protein Consumption Issue in Relation to Bone Building
Protein intake may also affect bone density. In theory, a diet high in proteins may increase the risk of fracture by raising the amount of acidity in the blood which “leaches” the calcium from the bone, weakening them over time. Numerous studies that have found an increased excretion of calcium in the urine associated with animal protein consumption, lending some credence to this theory. But I’m not buying it. Harvard researchers used the Nurses’ Health Study to attempt to see if a correlation exists. They found the data “yielded some evidence for the hypothesis”, with “small but significant increases in risk of forearm fracture”, but no evidence of increased hip fracture (Feskanich, 1995).
Since protein contains the important ingredients to rebuild bone – provided it can be broken down by the digestion (see calcium discussion above), it should be accompanied by potassium foods within the diet (as Dr. Atkins found). Potassium foods (celery, cabbage, parsley, broccoli, lemon) assist the body with the elimination of the acids from the body through the kidneys. My clients seem to like Combo Potassium (#1673-3) to minimize the adverse effects of needed animal protein in the diet.
The Weight factors in Relation to Bone Building
Most women who come to me with this concern (osteoporosis) are slight of build – that is, lightweights. They taught me that the body is intelligent and makes as much bone density as needed to support their weight/activities. More weight requires denser bones. Our ancestors didn’t have shopping carts and cars. We carried heavy things from the market which made our bones dense up for the load. We carried our children and grandchildren on us everywhere – no strollers, and our bones adjusted to the task. Now I know you don’t want to gain weight to dense up your bones. BUT, know this – your intelligent body can have all the ingredients to make bone but have no need to because of your light load, especially if you sit all day like I do. My Greater Trochanter (bone atop femur that inserts into hip) is not supporting my weight in the sitting position. AND besides all that, your bones don’t know that they are not passing a man-made test. They are just following the intelligent design program as instilled by their Creator. Options: you can provide needed ingredients and leave them at their proper density, or you can wear a weight vest or belt that puts your bones in compression, or carry your grandchildren around all day.
The Circulation Factors in Relation to Bone Building
The last thing my clients taught me about building bones was that those with circulation problems were likely to have problems building bones too. Those who bruise easily or have finger nails that crack are not delivering nutrients to the end of the line. It is the blood that carries nutrients to all the tissues. Again, good bone building materials in the diet does not mean they get where they are needed. Good circulation depends on open pipes (blood vessels) and thin blood. My personal favorite for this is Dr Christopher’s general circulation formula GC-X (#1212-1) Consult the circulation document of this website for more insights.
The Medication Problem in Relation to Bone Building
No discussion of building bones would be complete without addressing the adverse effect of pharmaceuticals on them (see below). The Unsupportive Methods post explains how to check your meds. Doctors can be trusted but they are often unaware of all the deleterious effects of the drugs they use. Pharmaceuticals cannot be trusted with your health. Here’s a list
- Aluminum-containing antacids
- Antiseizure medications (only some) such as Dilantin® or Phenobarbital
- Aromatase inhibitors such as Arimidex®, Aromasin® and Femara®
- Cancer chemotherapeutic drugs
- Cyclosporine A and FK506 (Tacrolimus)
- Glucocorticoids such as cortisone and prednisone
- Gonadotropin releasing hormone (GnRH) such as Lupron® and Zoladex®
- Medroxyprogesterone acetate for contraception (Depo-Provera®)
- Proton pump inhibitors (PPIs) such as Nexium®, Prilosec® and Prevacid®
- Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) such as Lexapro®, Prozac® and Zoloft®
- Tamoxifen® (premenopausal use)
- Thiazolidenediones (Actos® and Avandia®)
- Thyroid hormones in excess
Pharmaceutical Phactoids – In the unlikely event that your doc failed to warn you that…
Antidepressants and Risk of Bone Fracture
A recent article in the Archives of Internal Medicine (Vol. 67 No. 2. Jan. 22, 2007) reported that daily use of the most common antidepressants–SSRI’s– such as Prozac®, Zoloft®, Welbutron®, and others was found result in a 200% increase risk of bone fractures. This study looked at those 50 years of age and older. They were studied for five years. This is the age group most commonly at risk for osteoporosis. In this study, daily SSRI use was found to be associated with a significantly increased risk of falling (2,100% increased) and a lowered bone mineral density of the hip and the spine. All of these effects were dose dependent, meaning the longer you took the medications, the more problems you may have with them.
Antacid drugs and increased risk of hip fractures
There was an article in JAMA (12.27.2006 Vol. 296,No. 24) that reported on the elevated risk of hip fractures with the long-term use of antacid drugs (proton pump inhibiters such as Prilosec® and Nexium®) . This study showed a 59% increase risk if antacid medications are used for 4 years. There was a steady increase in hip fracture rates the longer these drugs were used.
[So, now we have someone taking an antacid drug and they begin to develop osteoporosis. What happens next? You know the answer–they will need another drug, this time an osteoporosis drug – but they cause jaw rot.]
Osteoporosis Drugs and Risk of Bone Fracture
The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism (2005) published cases of spontaneous traumatic hip fractures following Fosamax use. In 2007 the Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery reported the same thing. Most recently the Journal of Orthopaedic Trauma (May/June 2008) reported that Fosamax caused spontaneous severe hip fractures in women who took the drug for more than 5 years. The fractures occurred in the femur and in many cases the fractures were preceded by weeks or months of aching thigh bone. Almost all fractures occurred spontaneously while standing or walking. [Who reads these journals? Who warns these poor ladies?]
©Pat Block ND 2007
Index for this Post
- Making Bones and Teeth (a politically incorrect guide)
- The Calcium Issue in Relation to Bone Building
- The Hormone Issue in Relation to Bone Building
- The Protein Consumption Issue in Relation to Bone Building
- The Weight factors in Relation to Bone Building
- The Circulation Factors in Relation to Bone Building
- The Medication Problem in Relation to Bone Building
- Pharmaceutical Phactoids – In the unlikely event that your doc failed to warn you that…
Consider this…..I have learned more from very sick people than I have from double-blind, placebo-controlled, cross-over studies. My sick clients taught me how to get them well - things that even my teachers didn't know. I have such smart clients.
** Important Warning **Nothing on this site is FDA approved. Nothing I write here is intended to be medical advice. Follow my recommendations at your own risk. Results may vary, and blah, blah, blah. So if the required warnings have not scared you away, then you have a chance. I'm reporting here what kinds of approaches actually helped very sick people get well, AND the kinds of things that actually made them sick (and it usually isn't lack of exercise, weight, menopause or smoking - it is the underlying cause of all those things.)
** Important Posts **
In case you were wondering..B=Breakfast, L=Lunch, D=Dinner, b=bedtime. Make sure to read What to Expect on an Herbal Program (in the Herb menu) before beginning. Dosages given are about what my clients benefit from. You may be different. Begin slowly and see how each recommendation benefits you.
** Join the Discussion **This website is a work in progress and a sharing tool. Feel free to use the comment forms to share your tried and true 'something natural'.